States rights in the civil war essay

Starting from the Constitution, all the way until Abraham Lincoln is elected and South Carolina feels there is no possible way to repair a relationship with the other half of the country, there has been divides, arguments, and countless bills and acts passed to try to repair relationships. In the Upper house, states should be represented equally with two members apiece. Alexander Hamilton proposed that the new government take responsibility for the existing public debt.

States rights in the civil war essay

Ultimately, the North succeeded and the Federalists prevailed, but it was not until years after the Civil War and even reconstruction that the United States government was truly restructured to benefit all.

The Economy

Both sides were firmly rooted upon their goals, and it was not until after the end of the Civil War and Reconstruction that the United States was able to stand somewhat undivided upon the issue. It was, as the Southerners claimed, the flaws in this unbalanced, unspecific way of ruling a vast country that caused the Founding Fathers created the Constitution.

With many individual sets of laws and methods of activity, each state could help its people in the best possible, personalized way. Anti-federalists wanted to get rid of the excess power of the executive branch and the Necessary and Proper Clause, and add a Bill of Rights. The Necessary and Proper clause allowed the Legislative Branch to claim the power to pass any and all laws that would help the governing body carry out its goals.

Anti-federalists thought that this granted the central government too much power. Their idea was that if the central government could exercise whatever powers it deemed necessary, the state governments deserved the power to deem central government acts unconstitutional and power-greedy.

However, the rest of the Constitution contained little on how the Southerners would approach reforming the government to give the states more rights. Many components of the Confederate Constitution, were alike, if not the exact same, as many parts of the United States Constitution that caused Confederates anger.

These anti-federalists, in some ways, were like little children. They complained, but did not go about the right ways of achieving what they wanted.

They exited one government only to recreate it, and were angry at others as a result of their own actions. The new government the Confederates made was arguably even more Federalist than the old one, since the Confederacy could acquire new territory, slavery was universally protected, and Congress could make any laws necessary and proper.

States rights in the civil war essay

Any disputes over Confederate laws would be taken directly to national, not state, court. Ironically, the 11 states that exited the United States exercised held the reigns even tighter on their own people, going so far as to limiting who could vote and encouraging segregation.

During the period of the Articles of Confederation, when states possessed power and were united under a weak national government, the United States found itself failing under no supporting structure.

While under the Articles of Confederation, America was under severe debt and could not get out of it without the power to tax. Commerce was not regulated, and so states often engaged in competition amongst themselves.

Some states unfairly taxed merchants transporting goods to earn money. Individual states could not act in synchrony of each other as well, and often ideas clashed and fights arose.

The central government lacked any power to carry out actions to defend the states during war.

Civil War/ Causes Of The Civil War term paper

Eventually, with so much power, the states would have become truly individual without owing any duties to the central government. This was one of the reasons the Confederacy struggled to raise troops to fight during the Civil War. Perhaps one of the reasons the Confederacy was not a stable government was because of concealed goals.

The first state, South Carolina, seceded 3 months before abolitionist Abraham Lincoln was elected President. South Carolina, however, was very set on slavery — its economy depended almost entirely on it.

Ultimately, the North, which was mostly Federalists, held the advantage of an already established government, a larger population for the army, and an industry fit for manufacturing.States’ Rights during Civil War and Reconstruction During the mids, state’s rights were a subject of much controversy and disagreement.

As a result, after the Southern states seceded and the Civil War broke out, granting states’ rights was the goal of both Abraham Lincoln, who desperately wanted to keep the United States united, and.

The Events That Caused The American Civil War Causes Of The Civil War Summary States’ Rights The Missouri Compromise The Dred Scott Decision The Abolitionist Movement Abolitionist John Brown John Brown’s Raid On Harpers Ferry Slavery In America Harriet Tubman Underground Railroad Harriet Beecher Stowe Uncle Tom’s Cabin Secessionism Abraham Lincoln’s Election Civil War Causes .

The states secession from the union was a very controversial issue during the Civil war. Some people believe it was the rights of the states under the Constitution to seceded from the union when others believed it was unconstitutional and the states were wrong in doing so/5(4).

The civil war was a terrible rift in our nation, fought between the northern states, known as the union, and the southern states, known as the Confederate States of America.

The people’s opinions were so divided over the issues of the civil war. The Causes of the American Civil War Essay Example. The American Civil War of was fought between the Union (the northern states) and The Confederates (the southern states) under the presidency of Abraham Lincoln. States’ Rights during Civil War and Reconstruction During the mids, state’s rights were a subject of much controversy and disagreement.

As a result, after the Southern states seceded and the Civil War broke out, granting states’ rights was the goal of both Abraham Lincoln, who desperately wanted to keep the United States united, and.

States rights civil war essay